Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

What SEO risks arise from sitewide footer links exchanged with business partners?

The risk is that the arrangement matches patterns Google’s spam policies name as link spam. Two of the listed examples apply directly: “Excessive link exchanges (‘Link to me and I’ll link to you’) or partner pages exclusively for the sake of cross-linking”, and “Widely distributed links in the footers or templates of various sites” (Google’s spam policies). A reciprocal footer link is both at once: an exchange, repeated on every page of two sites. Whether a given arrangement is a problem depends on why it exists. The policies define link spam by purpose, as links created “primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings”. A partner credit that serves visitors is one thing. A swap arranged to pass ranking value is another, and a footer placement makes the second easy to produce at scale.

Placement scale

A footer link is not one link. It is one link on every page.

Site size Links created by one footer entry
50 pages 50
2,000 pages 2,000
40,000 pages 40,000

Exchanged between two partners, the pattern is mirrored: thousands of links in each direction, identical anchor text, the same position, appearing on the same day. Nothing about that resembles individual editorial decisions, and the policy’s example for footers and templates describes exactly that kind of wide distribution.

Scale also removes context. A link in an article about a joint project sits beside an explanation of the relationship. A footer link sits beside the copyright notice on a page about something else.

Scale is what separates this case from a pair of ordinary links between companies that work together. Where that ordinary exchange itself becomes a problem is covered in the guide to when reciprocal links between related companies can become manipulative.

Commercial relationship and intent

The same placement can come from different motives.

Arrangement Reading against the policy
A web agency credited in the footer of a site it built A credit for work done, and also the template-footer pattern, so the anchor and the link treatment matter
A parent company and its subsidiaries linking to each other in footers A real relationship that visitors may want to follow
Two unrelated businesses agreeing to add each other's "best [service] in [city]" link sitewide An exchange for ranking purposes; the policy's example
A supplier and a retailer listing each other as partners on every page Real relationship; the sitewide scale is more than the relationship needs
A network of local businesses all carrying each other's keyword-anchored footer links A link scheme
A sponsorship credit in the footer in return for payment A paid link; the policies ask for it to be qualified

Questions that expose intent:

  • Would the link exist if search engines did not?
  • Was anchor text negotiated?
  • Was the link described in the agreement as an SEO benefit?
  • Is the anchor the partner’s name, or a search phrase?

The policies give no number of links, no ratio, and no threshold at which an exchange becomes excessive. Any rule of thumb that supplies one is not from Google.

User relevance

Ask what a visitor gets from the link on a typical page.

Test Passes Fails
Does a visitor on this page have a reason to go to the partner? A manufacturer's site linking to its authorized service network A dentist's site linking to an unrelated roofing company
Is the relationship explained? "Part of the Northgate Group" A bare keyword link with no context
Is every page the right place? A group identity bar A partner relevant to one service, linked from all of them
Do visitors click it? Analytics shows use No recorded clicks

A link that fails these tests is doing nothing for visitors, which leaves ranking as the remaining explanation for its presence.

Safer citation practices

An illustrative arrangement and its repair. All names are invented.

Before: Ashby Kitchens and Corwin Flooring, two independent firms, agree to link to each other. Each adds a footer link on every page: “Flooring installation Ashby” pointing to Corwin, and “Kitchen fitters Ashby” pointing to Ashby Kitchens.

Aspect Before After
Placement Footer, every page One "Trade partners" page on each site, plus a mention on the project pages where both firms worked
Anchor Search phrase The company's name
Context None A sentence on what the partner does and how the firms work together
Scale Thousands of links each way A handful
Qualification None None needed if no payment is involved; <!–INLINECODE0–> or <!–INLINECODE1–> if the listing is paid for
Reason to exist Ranking Referral of customers who need the other trade

Options, from least to most change:

  1. Replace keyword anchors with company names.
  2. Move the link from the sitewide footer to a partners or about page.
  3. Add context that explains the relationship.
  4. Where money or services were exchanged for the link, qualify it. The policies state that sponsorship and advertising links are acceptable when qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" value.
  5. Where the link serves no visitor, remove it.

What the outcome of leaving such links in place would be for a particular site cannot be stated from the policy text. The policies name what counts as link spam. How any individual link is weighed is not something this guide can tell you.

For agencies, a credit in a client’s footer is worth handling consistently: the agency’s name as anchor, and a link treatment agreed with the client.

Footer links within a single site, to its own pages, raise a different question about navigation and usefulness, which is covered in the guide to when repeated sitewide footer links become excessive or unhelpful.

The warning: a reciprocal sitewide footer link combines two patterns the spam policies name, so it needs a reason to exist that has nothing to do with rankings.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *