usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO
What distinguishes earned digital PR links from links purchased as placements?
Updated November 15, 2026
Who decided to publish, and why. An earned link exists because an editor or writer judged that a story, a dataset, or an expert comment was worth covering, and chose to link to its source. No one paid for that decision, and the company had no control over whether the piece ran, what it said, or whether it linked. A purchased placement exists because money, goods, or services changed hands for the article or the link. Google’s spam policies treat the two differently. They list “Buying or selling links for ranking purposes” as link spam, and they also state that buying and selling links is “a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes”, acceptable where such links are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" value (Google’s spam policies). Payment is the dividing fact, and disclosure and link treatment follow from it.
Why coverage was published
Three questions separate the cases.
| Question | Earned | Purchased |
|---|---|---|
| Who decided the piece would run? | The publication's editorial staff | The buyer, by paying |
| Who controlled the content? | The writer; the company supplied information and had no approval | The buyer wrote it or approved it |
| Could the publication have declined, or covered it critically? | Yes | Not within the arrangement |
Earned coverage is uncertain by nature. A press release is sent and nothing may come of it. A journalist may use the data and link to a competitor’s analysis of it. That uncertainty is the evidence of editorial independence.
The distinction matters again when a campaign is counted. Paid placements are reported apart from earned coverage, as shown in the guide to measuring unique referring domains after a digital PR campaign.
Payment and placement signals
Payment is broader than an invoice for a link. The spam policies’ examples include “Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links”, “Exchanging goods or services for links”, and “Sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link”. They also name “Advertorials or native advertising where payment is received for articles that include links that pass ranking credit”.
Signals that a placement was bought:
- a rate card, a “sponsored post” price list, or a fee for “editorial review”;
- a contract or order that specifies the link, its anchor text, or its destination;
- a guarantee of publication, of a date, or of a “dofollow” link;
- the buyer supplying finished copy that runs unedited;
- an intermediary selling “guaranteed placements” on named sites;
- a free product sent on the understanding that a linked review will follow.
Signals of earned coverage:
- the publication was pitched and could have ignored the pitch;
- the journalist asked questions, sought other sources, or changed the angle;
- no specification of link or anchor was requested or given;
- the same story was covered differently by different outlets.
Required link attributes
Where a placement is compensated, Google’s guidance on outbound links asks the publisher to say so in the link: “Mark links that are advertisements or paid placements (commonly called paid links) with the sponsored value” (Google’s guidance on qualifying outbound links). The same page notes that nofollow “is still an acceptable way to flag them, though sponsored is preferred”.
Two layers of disclosure are involved, and they are separate obligations.
| Layer | Audience | What it requires |
|---|---|---|
| Link qualification | Search engines | A <!–INLINECODE3–> or <!–INLINECODE4–> value on paid links |
| Reader disclosure | People reading the page | A clear label that the content is sponsored or paid for, as advertising rules in the relevant country require |
The first is Google’s policy. The second is a matter of advertising and consumer protection law, which varies by country and which this guide does not set out. Qualifying a link does not satisfy the duty to tell readers, and a visible label does not qualify the link.
A buyer cannot make a paid link earned by asking the publisher to omit the attribute. That request is the conduct the policy describes.
Ethical decision examples
Two sample placements, both invented, compared.
| Aspect | Placement A | Placement B |
|---|---|---|
| What happened | A company published a survey; a regional news site wrote a story on the findings and linked to the report | A company paid a site a fee to run an article it supplied, containing a link to its service page |
| Decision to publish | The news editor's | Purchased |
| Content control | The journalist's; the company saw it when readers did | The company's |
| Payment | None | Fee paid |
| Classification | Earned editorial coverage | Paid placement |
| Reader disclosure | None needed | The article labeled as sponsored, per applicable advertising rules |
| Link treatment | The publisher's choice | <!–INLINECODE5–>, or <!–INLINECODE6–> |
| Legitimate use | Reported as PR coverage | Reported as advertising; valued for the audience it reaches, not as an editorial link |
Harder cases, with the reasoning:
| Situation | Reading |
|---|---|
| A journalist is sent a product to review, with no conditions | A review may follow or not. If the product was sent in exchange for a linked write-up, the policy's example applies |
| A publication charges a "processing fee" to consider contributed articles | Payment for publication; treat as paid |
| An agency promises "ten links on news sites" for a fixed price | The price buys placements; these are not earned, whatever the sites are |
| A trade body lists members, with links, in return for membership dues | A paid relationship; qualification of the links is the listing site's responsibility |
| A company sponsors an event and is credited on the event site | Sponsorship; the policy's allowance for qualified sponsorship links applies |
| A newspaper covers a story and adds <!–INLINECODE7–> to all outbound links by policy | Still earned coverage; link treatment is the publisher's choice |
Paid placements are not wrong in themselves. Advertising is a legitimate purchase when it is labeled, qualified, and bought for its audience. The fault lies in presenting one as the other, to readers or to search engines.
For internal reporting, keep two lists. Earned coverage goes in one, with the story and the outlet. Paid placements go in the other, with cost and disclosure status. Mixing them misstates both.
The markup itself, including how values combine and how to apply them across a site, is covered in the guide to how sponsored and affiliate outgoing links should be marked in HTML.
The distinction in one line: earned links are given by an editor who was free to refuse, and purchased placements are bought, disclosed, and qualified as advertising.
Add your comment to this answer