Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

Which fact-checking steps should happen before a factual SEO article is published?

Four steps, performed by someone other than the writer where possible: pull every checkable claim out of the draft, verify each against a primary source, confirm that every number and version is current and correctly stated, and decide what to do with the claims that could not be confirmed. The output is a list in which each claim carries a status. An article is ready when no claim is left unresolved, which can mean it was verified, reworded to what the evidence supports, or removed.

Claim extraction and prioritization

Read the draft once only to collect claims. A claim is any statement that could be wrong.

  • Numbers, dates, prices, measurements, percentages
  • Names, titles, and affiliations
  • Statements about what a law, rule, or policy requires
  • Statements about how a product or platform behaves
  • Quotations
  • Comparisons and superlatives: largest, first, most
  • Cause-and-effect statements

Put each in a table with its location in the draft. Then rank them, because time is finite.

Priority The claim Check
High Could cause harm, loss, or a wrong decision if false; concerns health, money, law, or safety; names a person or company Always, against a primary source
Medium Central to the article's argument; a specific number or date Always
Low Background that is widely documented and incidental Spot check

Opinions are not checked for truth, and they should be recognizable as opinions.

Drafts produced with AI assistance add one class of claim to collect: the citations themselves, which may point to sources that do not exist. Screening for those is covered in the guide to screening AI-assisted content drafts for fabricated citations.

Primary-source verification

For each claim, find the source that originates it and read the relevant passage.

  1. Open the source the writer cited. If none was cited, find one.
  2. Confirm the source is primary for this claim: the study, the regulation, the official documentation.
  3. Find the passage and compare it with the sentence in the draft.
  4. Check four things: the fact matches, the strength matches (may is not will), the scope matches (this group, this place, this period), and the source is current.
  5. For quotations, compare word for word.

A link that opens proves only that the page exists. A claim is verified when the passage has been read and says what the draft says. Google’s self-assessment questions include “Does the content have any easily-verified factual errors?” (Google’s guidance on helpful, people-first content). The step above is how that question is answered before a reader has to.

Finding the source is half of the job. How to credit it in the published text, for original research and for official references, is covered in the guide to attributing original research and official references in SEO articles.

Numbers and version control

Numbers deserve a pass of their own.

  • Recompute every total, percentage, and difference from its inputs.
  • Check units and currency, and that they are the same throughout.
  • Confirm that a figure in the text matches the same figure in a table, a caption, and the summary.
  • Check that each statistic carries its year and population.
  • For anything versioned (software, standards, laws, guidelines), confirm the version cited is the one in force, and state it.
  • Confirm dates: day, month, year, and the weekday if one is given.

Record the date the check was made. A fact verified today can change, and the record shows how old the verification is.

Escalation for uncertain claims

Some claims will not verify. Give each a decision.

Situation Decision
Source found; draft matches Approve
Source found; draft overstates Reword to match the source
Source found; draft is wrong Correct, and recheck anything that depended on it
Sources conflict Report both, or escalate to an editor
No primary source can be found Remove the claim, or attribute it explicitly as unverified reporting by a named party
Verification needs expertise the checker lacks Escalate to a qualified reviewer before publication

An editor’s checklist with statuses, shown with placeholder claims to demonstrate the format:

Claim (placeholder) Location Priority Source checked Status Action
A stated percentage of households use the product Introduction Medium Publisher's dataset, current edition Approved None
A rule takes effect on a stated date Section 2 High Official notice Approved after correction Date corrected
A product is described as the first of its kind Section 3 Medium No primary source found Unresolved Remove the superlative
A quotation from a named executive Section 4 High Original interview Approved None
A total computed from three figures Table 1 Medium Recomputed Approved after correction Total corrected
A statement about a treatment's effect Section 5 High Requires medical review Escalated Hold until reviewed

Publication rule: no row may remain unresolved or escalated at the time of publishing. Each must end as approved, corrected, reworded, or removed.

Practical safeguards that make the process hold:

  • The checker is not the writer. A second reader sees what the author’s familiarity hides.
  • Writers submit sources with the draft, one per claim.
  • Edits made after the check are themselves checked. A late rewrite can reintroduce an error.
  • The checklist is kept with the article, so an update can start from it.

This is the baseline for any factual article. Claims about health, finance, and law carry higher stakes and need stricter handling, described in the guide to handling uncertain claims in health, financial, or legal content.

The sequence: extract, rank, verify against the origin, recompute, resolve every open item, then publish.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *