Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

Why are self-serving review star snippets restricted for certain business webpages?

Because the business being reviewed is also the one choosing which reviews appear and marking them up. Google gave its reason when it introduced the rule in September 2019: “Reviews that can be perceived as ‘self-serving’ aren’t in the best interest of users” (Google’s 2019 announcement on review rich results). It defined the term in the same passage: reviews are self-serving “when a review about entity A is placed on the website of entity A”, whether directly in the site’s markup or through an embedded third-party widget. For pages using LocalBusiness or Organization markup, Google stopped showing review stars in those cases. The reviews themselves are not banned. Only the star display in search results is withheld.

Review-origin eligibility

The current guideline in Google’s documentation reads: “If the entity that’s being reviewed controls the reviews about itself, their pages that use LocalBusiness or any other type of Organization structured data are ineligible for star review feature” (Google’s review snippet documentation).

Three conditions combine in that sentence.

Condition Meaning
The reviewed entity controls the reviews The business collected, selected, or embedded them on its own site
The reviews are about the entity itself The subject is the business, not a product, recipe, or other item
The page uses LocalBusiness or another Organization type The markup describes the business as the thing reviewed

When all hold, the page is not eligible for stars. The 2019 announcement adds that embedding a third-party widget does not change this, because it “is seen as controlling the process of linking reviews”. It also states that the rule applies to AggregateRating as well as to Review.

Business-controlled review pages

Scenarios, read against the guideline:

Scenario Eligible for review stars? Reason
A plumber's home page with LocalBusiness markup and an aggregate rating built from testimonials it collected No Entity A's reviews on entity A's site
The same plumber embeds a widget showing its Google Business reviews, with rating markup No The documentation names this case: an embedded third-party widget
A directory site publishes visitors' reviews of plumbers, with markup on each listing Not excluded by this rule The directory is reviewing other businesses, not itself
A shop marks up customer reviews of a product on that product's page Not excluded by this rule The reviewed item is a product, a type the feature supports
A recipe site marks up visitors' ratings of a recipe Not excluded by this rule The announcement gives this as an allowed example
A company marks up reviews of itself using a different type to get around the rule No The reviews are still about the entity that controls them, and the markup misdescribes the page

“Not excluded by this rule” is not the same as approved. The other review guidelines still apply to those cases: ratings “must be sourced directly from users”, review content must be visible on the marked-up page, reviews must be about a specific item, and the documentation says “Don’t aggregate reviews or ratings from other websites”.

Structured-data limits

What the rule does and does not require, in the announcement’s own answers:

  • Does the markup have to be removed? The announcement says no: “you don’t need to remove them. Google Search just won’t display review snippets for those pages anymore.”
  • Does it bring a penalty? “You won’t get a manual action just for this”, with a recommendation to make sure structured data matches the guidelines.
  • Does it stop a business from showing testimonials on its site? No. The rule concerns the star display in search results.

A separate limit applies to every review, whoever publishes it. The documentation says: “Don’t include fake or undisclosed incentivized reviews on your page or in your structured data markup”. Its examples are reviews not based on a genuine experience and reviews written in exchange for a benefit without clear disclosure. Review authenticity can also be a legal matter, under consumer protection law that this guide does not cover.

So markup cannot turn a self-published rating into stars, and no markup makes an invented review acceptable.

Compliant alternatives

What a business can do instead.

Aim Compliant route
Show customers what others think Publish real testimonials on the site as visible content, with permission
Have ratings appear in search for the business Earn reviews on independent platforms, where the platform's own pages or the business's profile carry them
Stars on product pages Collect genuine customer reviews of each product and mark them up on that product's page, following the review guidelines
Describe the business accurately Keep LocalBusiness or Organization markup for name, address, and hours, without self-collected ratings
Respond to feedback Reply to reviews on the platforms where they were left

What to avoid:

  • switching the markup type to disguise a business review as a product review;
  • marking up a rating copied from another site;
  • creating a “product” page for a service solely to carry stars;
  • showing a rating in markup that visitors cannot see on the page.

A checklist for an existing site:

  1. Find pages with Review or AggregateRating markup.
  2. For each, name the item reviewed.
  3. If the item is the business itself and the page is the business’s own, expect no stars. Decide whether to keep or remove the rating markup; keeping it is permitted.
  4. If the item is a product or other supported type, confirm the reviews are from real users, visible on the page, and about that item.
  5. Run the Rich Results Test, bearing in mind that a valid result is not a promise of display.

Reviews on independent platforms raise a different practical question, how to reply in public without revealing who the customer is or what they bought, which is covered in the guide to answering public Google reviews without exposing private customer details.

The reason in one line: a business that controls the reviews about itself is not an independent source for them, so Google does not show its stars.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *