Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

When can reciprocal links between related companies become manipulative?

When the links exist to move rankings instead of to help visitors, and especially when they are exchanged in volume. Two companies that work together linking to each other is ordinary. A manufacturer names its distributors, the distributors name the manufacturer, and both links tell a visitor something true and useful. Google’s spam policies do not prohibit that. What they list as link spam is “Excessive link exchanges (‘Link to me and I’ll link to you’) or partner pages exclusively for the sake of cross-linking” (Google’s spam policies). The operative words are excessive and exclusively. Reciprocity is not the test. Purpose and pattern are.

Business relationship context

Start with whether the relationship is real and whether a visitor would care about it.

Relationship Would a visitor expect a link?
Parent company and subsidiary Yes
Manufacturer and authorized dealer Yes
Two firms that deliver a joint service Yes
A business and its trade association Yes
Sister brands under one owner, in unrelated markets On a group page that explains the ownership
Companies with common ownership and no commercial connection Not on that basis alone
Companies with no relationship that have agreed to swap links No

Common ownership alone does not make cross-linking useful. A property group that owns a dental practice, a tire shop, and a wedding venue can state the ownership on an about page. Linking each business to the others from service pages, with search-phrase anchors, serves no customer of any of them.

User-facing editorial purpose

Read each link as a visitor would.

  • Does the surrounding text explain why the other company is mentioned?
  • Is the anchor the company’s name, or a description of what the visitor will find?
  • Is the link on a page where the relationship is relevant?
  • Would the page be worse for a visitor if the link were removed?

The policies define link spam as links created “primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings”. A link that would be there if search engines did not exist is, by that definition, outside it.

Contrast in wording, with invented companies:

Version Text
Useful "Installation in the Ashby area is carried out by our authorized partner, Corwin Heating."
Manipulative "Looking for cheap boiler installation Ashby? Visit best boiler installers Ashby."

The first tells the visitor who does the work. The second is an anchor chosen for a search engine.

Pattern and scale

One exchange is not a pattern. The following are.

Signal Why it matters
Every company in a group links to every other, from many pages Volume beyond what any relationship explains
Identical keyword anchors in both directions Chosen for ranking, not for readers
Links placed on unrelated pages No connection to the content
A "partners" or "links" page listing dozens of unrelated businesses, each linking back The policy's "partner pages exclusively for the sake of cross-linking"
Links added on the same date across many sites Arranged, not editorial
A written agreement specifying links and anchors The exchange is the purpose
Three-way arrangements designed to hide reciprocity Concealment indicates intent

The policy text sets no count at which exchanges become excessive. A guide that gives one has made it up.

Two contrasting scenarios, both hypothetical.

Aspect Scenario 1 Scenario 2
Companies A boiler manufacturer and its regional service partner Eight unrelated local businesses with one owner
Links The manufacturer's "find an engineer" page lists the partner; the partner's about page names the manufacturer it is authorized by Each site carries links to the other seven on every service page
Anchors Company names "Best [service] in [town]" for each
Context Each link sits in a sentence explaining the relationship No explanation; a block of links
Count One link each way Thousands in total
Visitor value A customer finds who can service the product None; a tire customer has no use for a wedding venue
Reading A reciprocal link that serves users An exchange for the sake of cross-linking

Both scenarios involve related companies and both are reciprocal. Only the second matches the policy’s description.

Corrective options

Where a review finds the second kind, the fixes run from light to complete.

  1. Rewrite anchors to company names.
  2. Move the links to the pages where the relationship is relevant: an about page, a group page, a partner directory with descriptions.
  3. Add context that states the relationship.
  4. Reduce the number: one link where one will do.
  5. Remove links between businesses that have no connection a visitor would care about.
  6. Where a link must stay for business reasons and serves no editorial purpose, qualify it. Google’s guidance on outbound links describes rel="nofollow" for cases where “you’d rather Google not associate your site with, or crawl the linked page from, your site”, and rel="sponsored" for paid placements (Google’s guidance on qualifying outbound links).
  7. End any agreement that specifies links and anchors as the thing being exchanged.

A review record:

Field Content
Pair of sites Which two
Relationship What it is, in a sentence
Links each way Number, pages, anchors
Visitor purpose Stated, or "none found"
Decision Keep, rewrite, move, qualify, remove
Date and reviewer Who decided

If the review is prompted by a manual action for unnatural links, the cleanup and the reconsideration request follow Search Console’s process, and the record above becomes part of the evidence.

What cannot be stated is the effect of any particular set of reciprocal links on a particular site’s rankings. The policy describes the practice. It does not disclose how links are weighed.

Reciprocal links placed in sitewide footers multiply the pattern by every page of both sites, a case examined separately in the guide to the SEO risks of sitewide footer links exchanged with business partners.

The test: a reciprocal link is sound when each direction would make sense to a visitor on its own, and manipulative when the exchange is the reason for it.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *