Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

What evidence should be reviewed before deciding to use Google’s disavow tool?

Two things, and both must be present: a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links pointing to the site, and a manual action those links have caused or are likely to cause. That is the test in Google’s own guidance, which states that a site “should disavow backlinks only if” both conditions hold, joined in the original by a capitalized AND (Google’s Search Console help on disavowing links). The same page opens its decision step with the default: “In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool”. Absent that evidence, the decision is no action.

What a disavow does

A disavow file is a list of pages or domains whose links to your site you ask Google not to take into account. It does not remove the links from the web, and the guidance notes that disavowed links “will continue to be shown in the Links report”.

Facts from the guidance, checked on November 11, 2026:

Point Detail
Format A text file, one URL or domain per line, encoded in UTF-8 or 7-bit ASCII
Domains Prefixed with domain:, as in domain:example.com
Subpaths An entire subpath cannot be disavowed
Limits 100,000 lines and 2MB
Comments Lines beginning with # are ignored
Scope One list per property; a new upload replaces the existing list
Property type The tool does not support Domain properties
Timing After upload, "it can take a few weeks for Google to incorporate your list"
First step The guidance tells sites to try to have the links removed from the other site first, and to disavow what cannot be removed

The page describes the tool as “an advanced feature” that “should only be used with caution”, and warns that incorrect use can harm a site’s performance in search results.

Manual-action and unnatural-link context

The evidence falls into two groups, matching the two conditions.

Condition one: the links.

Evidence Source
Records of links bought, exchanged, or built through schemes Contracts, invoices, agency reports, old campaign plans
A sample of the links themselves, read page by page Search Console Links report export
Patterns: repeated commercial anchors, networks of similar sites, bursts tied to a vendor The same export, sorted and read
Who created them Internal history; previous owners of the domain

Condition two: the manual action.

Evidence Source
A manual action for unnatural links to the site Search Console, Manual Actions report
Its stated scope: whole site or particular sections The same report
No manual action, with a documented history of link schemes The report, plus the records above; this is the "likely will cause" case

The guidance gives an example of where such links come from: bad links built by the site owner, or by an SEO the owner hired, “via paid links or other link schemes”. Links that arrived unasked, from scrapers and low-quality directories, are not that.

What is not evidence:

  • a “toxicity” or “spam” score from a third-party tool;
  • an unfamiliar domain name;
  • a large raw count of links;
  • a ranking or traffic decline with no manual action and no history of link building;
  • a vendor’s sales audit.

Risk of disavowing legitimate links

The tool does what the file says. A file drawn up from a score-based export can include genuine citations from real publications. Disavowing those asks Google to disregard links the site earned.

Risks to weigh:

Risk How it arises
Legitimate links disavowed Bulk selection by score, or domain-level entries for sites with mixed content
An overbroad domain entry Disavowing a whole platform to exclude one page
A stale file A list uploaded years ago by a previous agency, never reviewed
A replaced file Uploading a new list overwrites the old; entries are lost if not merged
False reassurance Disavowing unsolicited links while the real cause of a decline goes uninvestigated

Before any new decision, download and read the existing file, if there is one. A site may be carrying a disavow list that no one now responsible for it has seen.

Documentation and escalation

A decision gate that defaults to no action:

1. Is there a manual action for unnatural links?
     Yes -> go to 4.
     No  -> go to 2.

2. Is there documented history of bought or schemed links,
   in considerable number?
     No  -> NO ACTION. Record the review. Stop.
     Yes -> go to 3.

3. Is a manual action likely, on the evidence of that history?
     No / unsure -> NO ACTION now. Monitor the Manual Actions report.
     Yes -> go to 4.

4. Identify the specific links that were built or bought.
   Request removal from the linking sites. Keep records.

5. For those that cannot be removed: prepare a disavow file
   limited to them. Second person reviews every line.

6. Upload. If a manual action exists, file a reconsideration
   request describing the cleanup.

Unsolicited links do not enter the gate at step 4. Only links the site, or someone acting for it, created do.

A record to keep for each review:

Field Content
Date and reviewer Who looked, and when
Manual Actions report Status on that date
Link history What records were checked; what they showed
Sample reviewed Number of linking pages opened and read
Decision No action, or proceed
Reason Which condition was or was not met
If proceeding Removal requests sent, responses, final file, reviewer of the file
Next review Date

Escalation points: any proposal to disavow should be approved by someone other than the person who drew up the list, and a decision to disavow at domain level should name the reason no page on that domain is worth keeping.

The record matters even when the answer is no action. It shows that the question was examined against Google’s stated conditions, which is the answer to the next vendor who arrives with a list of “toxic” links.

Links from automated copy sites are one reason the question gets raised, and how to assess them is covered in the guide to how a website should respond to unwanted backlinks from scraper sites.

The gate in one sentence: no considerable body of built links, or no actual or likely manual action, means no disavow.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *