Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

How should a website respond to unwanted backlinks from automated scraper sites?

In the ordinary case, by doing nothing. Scraper sites copy content automatically, links included, so a site that publishes content can collect links from them without having asked for any. Google’s guidance on its disavow tool says: “In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool” (Google’s Search Console help on disavowing links). The work is to confirm that the links are the unsolicited kind, to check for the specific evidence that would change the picture, and to keep a short record. Action is reserved for the cases where that evidence exists.

Identifying automated copy sites

Features that mark a linking site as an automated copy:

  • its pages reproduce your text, or fragments of it, with your internal links intact;
  • the same content appears from many other sources, with no original writing;
  • articles have no author, or a generic one, and no editing;
  • the domain name has no connection to any subject;
  • pages are created in bulk, with dates close to your own publication dates;
  • your links appear because they were in the copied text, not because anyone placed them.

A check that settles it: search for a distinctive sentence from one of your articles in quotation marks. Copies that carry your internal links along with the text are scrapers.

Scraping raises a different issue, the unauthorized copying itself. That is handled through copyright removal requests and is separate from the question of the links.

Distinguishing suspicious from harmful

Unwanted is not the same as harmful. Google’s spam policies define link spam as “creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings” (Google’s spam policies). A scraper that copied your page was not created by you and was not created to manipulate your ranking.

Feature Unsolicited scraper links Links that warrant a closer look
Origin Appeared without any action by you Follow a link-building campaign, by you or a past agency
Anchor text Whatever your own text contained Repeated commercial search phrases
Target Pages your own content links to Money pages chosen for ranking
Pattern Scattered, mirroring your publishing Bursts tied to a campaign or a vendor
History No record of buying links Invoices, vendor reports, or guest-post schemes in the past

The right-hand column describes links someone built on purpose. Those are the ones the disavow guidance has in view when it mentions “paid links or other link schemes”.

Spam-action evidence

The disavow guidance sets two conditions, joined by a capitalized AND. A site should disavow only if it has “a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links” pointing to it, and those links “have caused a manual action, or likely will cause a manual action”.

So the evidence to check is specific.

Evidence Where to look What it means
A manual action for unnatural links Search Console, Manual Actions report The condition is met; cleanup is required
No manual action Same report The second condition is not met by the report
A history of bought or schemed links Company records, agency reports A manual action is a real possibility; review the links
No such history Same Unsolicited links only
A traffic drop Performance report, with dates Not evidence about links by itself; check other causes first

A risk assessment worksheet for one batch of links, with sample entries:

Question Answer (sample) Weight
Did we, or anyone acting for us, create or pay for these links? No Decisive if yes
Is there a manual action? No Decisive if yes
Do the anchors match our own copied text? Yes Indicates scraping
Do the linking pages reproduce our content? Yes Indicates scraping
Is there a pattern of commercial anchors to money pages? No Would indicate a scheme
Has a past agency built links for us? Not on record Review if yes
Conclusion Unsolicited scraper links; no action

The worksheet does not claim that such links are harmless in every instance. It records that none of the documented triggers for action is present.

Escalation steps

Where the worksheet comes out clean:

  1. Record the review, with the date and the sample of links examined.
  2. Take no action on the links.
  3. Recheck the Manual Actions report on the regular schedule.

Where it does not:

  1. If a manual action exists, read its description and scope.
  2. Identify the links that were built or bought. Scraper copies are not the target.
  3. Ask the linking sites to remove those links, and keep records of the requests.
  4. Consider the disavow tool for the remainder, under the conditions in Google’s guidance.
  5. Submit a reconsideration request describing what was done.

What not to do:

  • disavow every unfamiliar domain as routine hygiene;
  • pay a service that sells “toxic link” cleanup on the strength of a third-party score;
  • pay a scraper site that offers to remove links for a fee;
  • attribute a ranking change to scraper links without first checking for other causes;
  • email hundreds of scraper sites that have no one to read the message.

The disavow guidance itself carries a warning: “This is an advanced feature and should only be used with caution”, because incorrect use can harm a site’s performance in search. A file that disavows legitimate links removes links the site earned.

If a scraper’s copy appears in search results in place of the original, that is the copying problem again, handled through a copyright removal request and not through the links.

When the evidence does point toward action, the decision to file a disavow has its own gate, set out in the guide to what evidence should be reviewed before deciding to use Google’s disavow tool.

The rule: identify the links as unsolicited, check for a manual action and for a history of built links, and if neither is present, leave them alone.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *