Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

How can external backlinks to discontinued pages be preserved through suitable redirects?

By redirecting each discontinued URL, permanently, to the surviving page that best does the same job for the reader who follows the link. A link from another site was placed for a reason: the author pointed to a particular guide, product, or figure. If the redirect delivers a page that serves that reason, the citation still works. If it delivers something unrelated, the visitor is misled and the redirect may not be treated as one. Google’s guidance on site moves warns against sending “many old URLs to one irrelevant single URL destination, such as the home page”, adding that this “might be treated as a soft 404 error” (Google’s guidance on site moves with URL changes). Where no suitable successor exists, the accurate response is no redirect at all.

Identifying URLs with valuable referring pages

Before removing pages, list the URLs that other sites link to.

Sources:

  • the Links report in Search Console, top linked pages, exported;
  • a third-party backlink index, as a second list;
  • server logs or analytics, for old URLs that still receive referral visits.

For each discontinued URL with external links, open a sample of the linking pages and note what they cited it for. This is the information the redirect decision depends on, and no export contains it.

Field to record Example (hypothetical)
Discontinued URL /guides/boiler-pressure-2019/
Linking pages 14, including two trade publications
What they cite it for The explanation of normal pressure range
Referral visits, last 12 months 310

Some of these links will already be lost by the time the list is made. Whether winning one back is worth more than seeking a new one is weighed in the guide to when reclaiming a lost backlink is more worthwhile than prospecting for a new one.

Choosing relevant successor destinations

The successor must answer the purpose of the incoming links.

Old page Candidate Suitable?
A guide, replaced by a newer edition The new edition Yes
A product, replaced by its successor model The successor's page Yes, if the page says it replaces the old model
A product, discontinued with no successor The category page Only if the category helps someone who wanted that product; otherwise no
An article merged into a longer guide The guide, ideally the relevant section Yes
A research report, withdrawn Nothing equivalent No redirect
A campaign page for a past event The current event's page Yes, if it is the same recurring event
Any page The home page No, unless the old page was itself a home page

A dead URL to successor map for a hypothetical site:

Discontinued URL Linked for Successor Action
/guides/boiler-pressure-2019/ Pressure range explanation /guides/boiler-pressure/ 301
/products/thermostat-t100/ The T100 product /products/thermostat-t200/ (states it replaces the T100) 301
/blog/winter-checklist-part-2/ Checklist steps /guides/winter-heating-checklist/ (merged) 301
/research/2018-survey/ Survey figures None; data withdrawn as outdated 410, no redirect
/offers/spring-2021/ A past promotion None 404 or 410, no redirect
/team/former-engineer/ A person's profile None 404 or 410, no redirect

The rows marked as having no successor are as much a part of the map as the others. A redirect from a withdrawn survey to the home page would tell every reader who follows a citation that the figures are somewhere on the site, when they are not.

Where a valuable page has no successor and its links matter, there is a third option: keep the page. Mark it as archived or superseded, and leave it at its URL.

Redirect implementation

Use a permanent, server-side redirect. Google’s documentation says: “Use permanent redirects when you’re sure that the redirect won’t be reverted”, and lists HTTP 301 and 308 as the permanent server-side redirects (Google’s documentation on redirects).

Rules:

  • One hop. The old URL redirects straight to the final destination, not through a chain.
  • One to one. Each old URL has its own considered destination. Pattern rules are fine where the mapping is truly mechanical, such as a renamed folder.
  • The destination returns 200 and is indexable.
  • Internal links are updated to point at the destination directly.
  • Redirects stay in place. For site moves, the guidance says to “Keep the redirects for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year”. External links do not expire, so a redirect that serves them has no natural end date.

A sample rule set, in the form used by Apache configuration:

Redirect 301 /guides/boiler-pressure-2019/ /guides/boiler-pressure/
Redirect 301 /products/thermostat-t100/ /products/thermostat-t200/
Redirect 301 /blog/winter-checklist-part-2/ /guides/winter-heating-checklist/
Redirect gone /research/2018-survey/

The syntax differs by server. The map, not the syntax, is the part that needs judgment.

Checking linking context

After implementation, test from the linker’s side.

  1. Request each old URL and confirm a single 301 to the intended destination, or the intended 404 or 410.
  2. Open three linking pages for each redirected URL. Read the sentence containing the link, follow it, and ask whether the destination supports what the sentence says.
  3. Where the destination no longer supports it, for instance a cited figure that the new edition changed, consider telling the publisher. A short note with the updated figure is a courtesy.
  4. Watch the page indexing report in Search Console for the old URLs. A redirected URL reported there as a soft 404 is a prompt to recheck whether its destination is a real equivalent.
  5. Review referral visits to the destinations.

For the most important citations, the durable fix is a corrected link. Ask the publisher to update the URL where that is practical. The redirect remains as the safety net.

What a redirect preserves is the path for readers and the association between the old address and its replacement. This guide makes no claim about how much ranking value passes through any given redirect.

Links from other sites are one half of the picture. The site’s own links to removed pages need repair as well, by a different method, described in the guide to repairing broken internal links that return HTTP 404 at scale.

The rule: redirect a discontinued URL only to a page that would satisfy the person who followed the original link, and where there is none, let the URL say so.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *