Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

What should happen to an ecommerce product URL when the item is permanently discontinued?

One of three things, chosen by what a visitor arriving at that URL still needs. If a true replacement exists, redirect permanently to it. If there is no replacement and people still have reasons to visit, such as manuals, parts, compatibility information, or reviews, keep the page as a clearly marked archive. If neither applies, let the URL return a not-found or gone response, with a helpful error page. The mistake to avoid is the automatic one: redirecting every discontinued product to the home page or a broad category. Google’s guidance on site moves warns that redirecting many old URLs to an irrelevant single destination “might be treated as a soft 404 error” (Google’s guidance on site moves with URL changes). That warning is written about moves, and the reasoning carries over. A redirect is a statement that the destination replaces the original.

Whether there is a true replacement

A replacement is a product a buyer of the old one would accept as its successor.

Candidate True replacement?
The next model in the same line, announced as the successor Yes
The same product under a new name or number Yes
A new version with the same function and compatibility Yes
A similar product from another brand No; an alternative, not a successor
A product in the same category with a different function No
The category page No
The home page No

Confirm with the people who know the catalog. The manufacturer’s own statement that one model replaces another is a sound basis.

Where the successor differs in ways that matter, such as a part that fits different equipment, it is not a replacement for the purpose of a redirect, even if the manufacturer markets it as the next model.

Keep an archive versus redirect

A discontinued product’s page can still be useful after the last unit is sold.

Reasons to keep it:

  • owners look for the manual, specifications, or dimensions;
  • spare parts, consumables, or accessories are still sold;
  • compatibility information lists the product by name;
  • reviews help buyers of used units, or buyers comparing the successor;
  • other sites link to it as a reference;
  • warranty and support information applies to units already sold.

Reasons to redirect instead: a true successor exists, and the old page has nothing of lasting use that the successor’s page lacks.

A decision table:

Case Replacement? Lasting user purpose? Treatment
Replaced Yes Little beyond the successor Permanent redirect to the successor; the successor's page states that it replaces the old model
Replaced, with support needs Yes Yes: manuals, parts Keep as an archive page; link prominently to the successor
Archived No Yes Keep as an archive page; mark as discontinued; link to alternatives, parts, and support
Unreplaceable No No Return 404 or 410; remove internal links
Recalled or unsafe Not relevant Safety information Keep a page with the recall notice and instructions; do not redirect it away

An archive page should say what it is.

Northgate T100 Thermostat
This product has been discontinued and is no longer for sale.

Replaced by: Northgate T200 Thermostat  [link]
Still available: T100 wall plate, T100 sensor  [links]
Support: installation manual (PDF), warranty terms  [links]

Specifications and description  [retained]
Customer reviews  [retained]

The buy button is removed. The price is removed, or shown as historical. Nothing on the page suggests the item can be ordered.

Status codes and customer help

Treatment Status Notes
Redirect to successor 301 or 308 Google's redirect documentation lists these as the permanent server-side redirects and says to use permanent redirects "when you're sure that the redirect won't be reverted"
Archive page 200 The page has real content and says the product is discontinued
No page 404 or 410 The error page offers search and links to current categories

The wording in the first row is from Google’s documentation on redirects.

For an archive page, the structured data should agree with the page. Google’s merchant listing documentation includes an availability value of https://schema.org/Discontinued, defined as “The item has been discontinued” (Google’s merchant listing structured data documentation). A page that shows “discontinued” to visitors and “in stock” in markup contradicts itself. Remove the item from product feeds.

What not to do:

  • return 200 with an empty “product not found” message at the old URL;
  • redirect to a search results page;
  • redirect to the home page;
  • leave the page live with a working buy button;
  • delete the page while category listings and guides still link to it.

Customer help on whichever page the visitor reaches: say that the product is discontinued, name the successor or alternatives, and point to support for existing owners.

Link preservation

Before choosing, find out what points at the URL.

Source of links Check Consequence
Other websites Links report in Search Console Redirect or archive so those citations lead somewhere relevant
The site's own pages Crawl of the site Update or remove each internal link
Buying guides and articles Content search for the product name Rewrite the passage; link to the successor or the archive
Sitemaps Sitemap files Remove redirected and removed URLs; keep archive URLs if they are meant to be indexed
Paid campaigns and emails Campaign lists Update destinations

Where a product page has attracted citations for information it contains, such as a specification table that reference sites link to, an archive preserves what was cited. A redirect to a successor preserves it only if the successor’s page carries the same information.

Internal links to a redirected URL should be changed to point at the destination directly, and links to a removed URL should be taken out.

Record each decision: the old URL, the case it fell under, the treatment, the destination if any, the date, and who decided. Products leave a catalog year after year, and the record is what keeps their treatment consistent.

Review archives periodically. An archive page kept for manuals can be retired when support ends, at which point the same three options apply again.

The earlier stage, an item that is unavailable now and expected to return, calls for different handling, described in the guide to how temporarily out-of-stock product pages should be managed for organic search.

The rule: redirect only to a true successor, keep an archive where owners and researchers still need the page, and otherwise let the URL honestly report that the product is gone.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *