Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

When should two supporting articles within one topic cluster link directly to each other?

When a reader finishing a section of one has a specific question that the other answers. Two articles under the same parent topic are related by definition, and that alone is not a reason to link them. The reason has to be a next step: doing the first task raises the second, or a decision in one depends on a fact in the other. Where that bridge exists, link at the sentence where the question arises. Where it does not, leave the two connected through their parent page, which already links to both.

Task adjacency

Two supporting articles are adjacent when the tasks they describe touch.

Relationship Example pair Link?
Sequence: one task follows the other Sealing air leaks in an attic, then insulating the attic Yes, in the direction of the sequence, and back as a prerequisite
Dependency: a decision needs a fact from the other Choosing an insulation material, and how insulation is rated Yes, from the decision to the fact
Alternative: the reader may be in the wrong article Insulating walls from inside, and insulating walls from outside Yes, both ways, near the top
Consequence: doing one creates a risk covered by the other Insulating a crawl space, and controlling crawl space moisture Yes
Shared topic only Attic insulation, and the history of fiberglass No
Parallel cases with no crossover Insulating a garage, and insulating a basement No, unless a reader with one is likely to have the other

The first four rows have a bridge. The last two are related by subject and nothing else.

Products can be adjacent in the same sense: one is used with another. Linking them so that both visitors and crawlers find the pairing is covered in the guide to how related-product links can expose complementary products to search crawlers.

Reader next-step value

Test each proposed link with one question: at this point in the article, what does the reader need next, and is it in the other article?

Map the pair before writing the link. For two sibling articles on home insulation:

Article A Article B
Title Air sealing an attic Adding attic insulation
Purpose Find and close the gaps where air escapes Choose and install insulation to the right depth
Bridge question "I have sealed the leaks. What now?" "Do I need to do anything before I insulate?"
Where the question arises The final section, after the sealing steps The preparation section, before installation
Link from A to B "With the leaks sealed, the next step is adding insulation to the recommended depth"
Link from B to A "Sealing comes before insulating, so seal attic air leaks first"
Destination purpose B takes the reader forward A sends the reader back to a prerequisite

Both links pass the test. Each sits where its bridge question occurs, and each tells the reader why to follow it.

If no bridge question can be written for a pair, there is no link to add.

A widget that fills a related-posts box cannot apply this test, which is how irrelevant links arrive. That failure is described in the guide to how automatic related-post widgets can create contextually irrelevant internal links.

Avoiding circular filler

Three habits turn sibling links into noise.

  • Linking every sibling to every other. In a cluster of ten articles, that is ninety links, and the reader cannot tell which matter.
  • A block of related articles at the foot of each page that lists the whole cluster. The parent page already does that job.
  • Reciprocal links by reflex. A links to B for a reason, so B is given a link to A without one.

Google’s link guidance offers a useful restraint: “Think about what other resources on your site could help your readers understand a given page on your site, and link to those pages in context” (Google’s guidance on crawlable links and anchor text). In context is the operative phrase. The same page says there is “no magical ideal number of links”.

A link back is justified by its own bridge. In the example above, B links to A because sealing is a prerequisite, not because A linked to B.

Link placement examples

Where the link sits decides whether it is used.

Placement Effect
In the sentence where the question arises The reader sees it at the moment of need
At the start, as a prerequisite or an alternative Saves a reader in the wrong article from reading on
At the end, as the next step Catches the reader who finished
In a generic related-links block Easy to overlook, and gives no reason to follow

Three placements, written out.

Prerequisite, near the top of the insulation article:

Before adding insulation, close the gaps around pipes, wires, and the attic hatch. Our guide to air sealing an attic covers where to look and what to use.

Dependency, mid-article in a material comparison:

The two materials differ in their rating per inch. If the figures are unfamiliar, see how insulation R-values work.

Alternative, at the start of an article on insulating walls from inside:

This guide assumes the walls are closed and finished. If the siding is being replaced, insulating walls from the outside may be the better route.

The bold text marks the link. In each case the anchor names the destination’s subject, and the sentence would still be useful with the link removed.

Review sibling links when either article changes.

  1. If the section holding the link is rewritten, check that the bridge still exists.
  2. If the destination article narrows or widens its scope, check that it still answers the bridge question.
  3. If an article is merged or removed, repoint or delete the links to it.

And keep the cluster’s structure in view. Sibling links supplement the vertical links through the parent page. They do not replace them. How a parent page and its supporting articles should link to each other is covered in the guide to connecting a parent topic page to its supporting articles.

The test: write the bridge question. If you can, link at the sentence where it arises. If you cannot, the parent page is connection enough.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *