Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

Why can a website rank well organically yet perform poorly in the local map pack?

Because the two results are different things, drawn from different sources and ordered on different grounds. The organic listings rank web pages. The map pack lists Business Profiles, and Google’s help states what those are based on: “Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity” (Google Business Profile help on local ranking). A site can be the best page on a subject and belong to a business that is far from the searcher, lists a different primary category, or has an incomplete profile. Strong pages do not move a business closer to the person searching. The gap between the two positions is expected once it is clear that neither result is a version of the other.

Different surfaces and local relevance

Aspect Organic results Map pack
What is listed Web pages Business Profiles
Source The site's content The profile's information: name, category, address, hours, reviews
Ordered by Google's ranking systems for web pages Relevance, distance, and prominence, as the help page's headings name them
Where the business is One input among others Central
Who can appear Any site, wherever the publisher is Businesses with a profile that fits the search and the place

Relevance means something different in each. For the map pack, Google’s help defines it as “how well a Business Profile matches what someone is searching for”. The match is with the profile. A website full of well-written service pages does not supply a category the profile lacks.

Profile and proximity factors

The help page names three factors.

  • Relevance: how well the profile matches the search. The page advises providing “complete and detailed business info”.
  • Distance: how far each business is from the customer who is searching. Where the customer does not share a location, the page says Google uses what it knows about their location.
  • Prominence: “how well-known a business is”. The page says this factor is also based on “how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have”.

Distance accounts for cases that otherwise look puzzling. A business does not have one map position. It has a position for each place a search is made from. From an office across the city, a firm that tops the organic results may sit outside the map pack because several competitors are nearer to that searcher. Nothing is wrong with its site.

Prominence is where the wider web comes in. Links from other websites to the business are named in the help page, and a strong site is one way such links are earned. That is a contribution to one factor of three. It does nothing about distance, and it does not stand in for the profile.

Causes on the profile side, to check in order:

Check Why it matters
Is there a verified profile? The help page says verification makes a business more likely to show up
Is it suspended or duplicated? A suspended profile is not shown; duplicates divide the business's information
Is the address correct and the pin in the right place? The location is the business's side of the distance factor
Are the hours set, including special hours? Hours are among the information the help page asks for
Is the profile complete and accurate? The help page says businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local results

Business category signals

Category is the profile’s direct statement of what the business is. Google’s help on categories says “The categories you select affect your local ranking on Google” (Google Business Profile help on managing your business category), and gives the example of a primary category leading to a business being shown for related searches.

A mismatch produces exactly the split in the question.

Business Website Primary category Result
A firm that mostly installs heat pumps Strong pages on heat pump installation A general contractor category Pages rank; profile is a weak match for "heat pump installer"
A dental practice offering orthodontics A detailed orthodontics section Dentist Orthodontics pages rank; the profile matches "dentist" better than "orthodontist"

Both rows are illustrations. In each, the site says one thing and the profile another. The remedy, where the category is wrong, is to choose the category that describes the business accurately. It is not to add categories for searches the business would like to appear in.

Comparing controlled observations

A single search proves little, because results depend on where the searcher is, the device, and the moment. To compare the two surfaces, hold everything fixed except the thing being examined.

Paired observation protocol:

  1. Choose one query.
  2. Choose a fixed location, stated as a point, and keep it for every observation.
  3. Use one device type, signed out.
  4. Record the organic position of the site and the map pack position of the profile in the same search.
  5. Record the date and time, since hours can affect what is shown.
  6. Repeat from a second fixed location, changing nothing else.
  7. Repeat on another day.

A recording sheet, with placeholder entries to show the layout. These are not observations.

Query Location Device Date, time Organic position In map pack? Nearest competitors in pack
[query] Point A, 0.5 miles from premises Mobile [date] [n] Yes or no [names]
[query] Point B, 6 miles from premises Mobile [date] [n] Yes or no [names]

Reading the pairs:

Pattern Likely explanation to test
In the pack near the premises, out of it farther away; organic steady Distance
Out of the pack everywhere, including next to the premises Profile: verification, category, suspension, duplication
In the pack for one query, not for a close variant Category or profile relevance
In the pack during opening hours only Hours
Organic position also varies by location A separate effect on organic results

Confounders to name in any report: personalization from a signed-in account, the precision of the location used, differences between mobile and desktop layouts, and the fact that tools which simulate a location are approximations. Report observations with their conditions, and do not reduce them to a single “local rank”.

No one factor accounts for every case. The help page states: “There’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google”, and says Google keeps the details of the algorithm confidential. What a business can do is make the profile accurate and complete, and accept that distance is not adjustable.

Location also changes the ordinary web results, by a different mechanism from the one described here, and that is covered in the guide to how a searcher’s physical location changes the organic ranking order for the same query.

The summary: the organic result reflects the page, the map pack reflects the business and its distance from the searcher, and each has to be diagnosed separately.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *