Skip to the indexed answers
Digital Marketing Index

usdigitalmarketingindex.com SEO

When should blog tag archives be indexable by Google?

A tag archive should be open to indexing when it works as a page a visitor would be glad to land on: it gathers a meaningful number of posts on a subject people look for, it is not a near copy of a category or another tag, and someone keeps it in order. A tag archive that lists two posts, duplicates a category, or exists because an author typed a new word once should be kept out of the index or removed. Leaving a page indexable is permission, not a promise. Google decides what to index, and a noindex rule only takes effect on a page Google is able to crawl.

Tag utility and depth

Three properties make a tag archive useful.

  • Depth: enough posts that the page is a collection. A tag attached to one or two posts is a duplicate of those posts’ excerpts.
  • Distinctness: the set of posts differs from every category and from every other tag. If the tag kitchen-remodel and the category Kitchen Remodeling list the same posts, one of them is redundant.
  • Demand: the tag names something readers look for, as shown by site search or by queries in Search Console.

Tags created freely by authors can fail the second property. Singular and plural forms, synonyms, and misspellings each produce their own archive.

Unique curated introductions

An archive that is a bare list of excerpts gives a visitor from search little to go on. One that opens with a short written introduction, saying what the tag covers and where to start, behaves more like a topic page.

Write introductions only for tags you intend to keep. An introduction does not rescue a tag with two posts, and writing fifty introductions for fifty marginal tags is effort better spent merging them.

Noindex or consolidation choices

For each tag there are four possible actions.

Action When it fits How
Keep indexable Deep, distinct, in demand, maintained Add an introduction; link to it from relevant posts
Noindex Useful to visitors on the site, weak as a search landing page Robots meta tag or X-Robots-Tag header with noindex
Merge Two or more tags mean the same thing Reassign posts to one tag; redirect the others to it
Delete One or two posts, no demand Remove the tag; redirect its archive to the closest category

One technical condition applies to the noindex route. Google’s documentation on robots meta tags says these settings “can be read and followed only if crawlers are allowed to access the pages that include these settings” (Google’s robots meta tag documentation). Blocking tag archives in robots.txt and adding noindex to them at the same time defeats the noindex, because the rule is never read.

Maintenance thresholds

Run the audit below on every tag, and repeat it on a schedule. Each row gives the input to check, the action, and the condition that decides pass or fail. The three rows are hypothetical and stand for the types of tag a blog accumulates.

Tag (hypothetical) Input to verify Action Pass or fail
heat-pumps Post count; overlap with categories; queries containing the phrase Keep indexable, write introduction Pass if it holds a substantial set of posts not listed together elsewhere, and the phrase appears in query or site search data
heat-pump, heatpumps Whether another tag lists the same posts Merge into heat-pumps and redirect Fail as separate archives if their post lists overlap the main tag
2019-conference Post count; whether posts are still current; any demand Noindex, or delete if posts are retired Fail for indexing if the posts are few and dated and no one searches the phrase

Then apply three standing rules.

  1. Set a minimum for indexable tags that suits your blog, and write it down. The number is your editorial policy, not a figure from Google.
  2. Control tag creation. Let authors choose from an approved list, with additions reviewed by an editor.
  3. Recheck after publishing volume changes. A tag that was thin can grow into a collection, and one that was current can go stale.

A checklist for the review itself:

  • Input: full list of tags with post counts. Action: flag every tag below the minimum. Pass: none remain indexable without a recorded reason.
  • Input: post lists for each tag and category. Action: flag pairs with heavily overlapping lists. Pass: each overlapping pair has been merged or one side set to noindex.
  • Input: robots.txt and the tag archive template. Action: confirm noindexed archives are crawlable. Pass: no noindexed archive is blocked in robots.txt.
  • Input: Search Console page indexing report filtered to tag URLs. Action: compare indexed tag URLs with the list you intend to be indexed. Pass: the two lists match, allowing for time after changes.

Tag archives are produced by the system. A page a person builds to introduce a subject is a different thing with different upkeep, compared in the guide to what distinguishes an editorial topic hub from a blog category archive.

The test for any single tag: would you link to this archive from an article because it helps the reader? If yes, it can be indexed. If you would be embarrassed to send a reader there, search should not send one either.

Link trail

Reader comments on this answer

Add your comment to this answer

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *